I have decided to stay with him. I bought a No EXP chip. We have the second part of the Legendary Items to do. Solo with the Dwarf at the gate. Scofflaw has done this, fighting a no difficult battle with the watcher again. Afterwards he went into Moria to talk to Tulk and receive the second item, different for each class.
Allen fought the squid and then went into Moria and got the pocket item. I emailed both of you a crafted relic that you can attach to your weapon. It will need to be deconstructed first at a Relic Master (there is one in South Bree across the road from the stable guy)
P.S. I'll make a second one so that there is one for the weapon and one for the pocket item but there is a cooldown and I can't make more until tomorrow.
Just for info, returning to Moria is a pain. There is a Forge Master in Dolven View and the Stable Master at entrance to Moria has a goat taxi to Dolven View.